As preppers, one of the hardest things that we can do is find balance in our preps. For various reasons we tend to overdo or neglect. In today’s article & it’s accompanying podcast, we take a look at eight different things we as preppers overdo or tend to emphasize too much or spend “way too much time and money” on.
We published an article and podcast last week about “Six Things Preppers Don’t Do Enough Of (CLICKY)“, so we thought it was time to go ahead and look at the other side of the coin.

Note on Spice’s holding the gun… she finds it very uncomfortable to extend her index finger on this gun, so she wraps her finger on the grip behind the trigger, Not quite as fast as “normal” but entirely safe since here finger blocks the trigger from being pulled.
Here are eight things that a lot of preppers overdo:
- Preppers Overdo Guns – I love guns. I’m a bit of a firearms fanatic. As far as I’m concerned, the more guns the better. The problem is, for prepping purposes, owning several safes full of guns is both unnecessary and it limits the amount of resources that are available for the rest of our preps.
- Preppers Overdo Knives – Sorry, knife guys, I hate to put this one out there but I know preppers who spend an absolutely RIDICULOUS amount of money on knives and call it prepping. It’s not. Just like guns, buy what you need and don’t scrimp on the quality, buy adequate spares, and move on. It’s OK to have knife and gun collecting as a hobby, but don’t use money needed for other preps to fund your obsession.
- Preppers Overdo Tacticool Gear – I go to gun shops, gun shows and “prepper shows” from time to time, and I have to admit I have actually laughed out loud at some of the pointless and patently ridiculous tacticool junk being sold and purchased. Hey, if you want to dress like a member of a SWAT team, that’s your business. I don’t care. But if your AR-15 weighs in at 17 pounds because it’s so loaded with tacticool garbage you will never use, well… you may want to back it off a bit.
- Preppers Overdo Fire Starters – I have to chuckle at some of the absolutely ridiculous threads I’ve read on prepper forums about the various fire starting methods, and the inordinate amount of time and effort put into alternative fire starters. Here’s a hint, we are PREPPERS, not Bear Whatshisname. If you want to have fire starters to last you for years, buy a case of Bic lighters and you are good to go. If it’s a long-term situation … you have years to master that bow drill.
- Preppers Overdo Thirty-Year Shelf Life Food – I know it happens every day; somebody realizes how much prepping is needed for survival, so they decide to knock out the food problem and order one of those “Year’s Supply Of Food” things from one of the big freeze-dried prepping food companies. Other than we find most of those ads horribly misleading (expect to see a story series on this in the future), there’s nothing wrong with having long-term storage food. The problem is when people stop at that and think they have it covered. It’s far more important to be able to GROW your own food than have X-many years worth in storage, because one of two things is likely to happen. A) You never use it; B) You use it, then when it’s gone if you are not growing your own by then, you starve. Better to implement a food growing system which you supplement with long term storage than having the long term stuff being your only option. Besides…do you really want to eat nothing that doesn’t come out of a 5 gallon bucket for years at a time? Not to mention the likely vitamin deficiencies…
- Preppers Overdo Electronic gadgets. So many times I see people prepping with electronic gadgets. While there is nothing wrong with having a few electronic items (as long as you have a way to charge them) if we get into an extended situation, they cannot be counted on. They can also be trashed immediately by an EMP, or have their use degraded very quickly by limited access to recharging; and they tend to be fairly fragile.
- Preppers Overdo Cell phones instead of a solid communication plan for families. A friend of mine lives in the US Virgin Islands. The three days before the recent hurricane arrived, know what the cell phone companies did? They disassembled their cell phone towers and lashed the parts to the ground. They then flew their workers out of the path of the storm. Good thing they did, it saved them a ton of money because the storm would have just destroyed the towers if they were up. Cell phone service in a grid-down scenario cannot be counted on. Cell service in any emergency can’t be counted upon in fact, as history has shown the system tends to overload. Instead, we need to have a sound, pre-determined meet-up plan with our loved ones, so we know if the SHTF where they will go.
- Preppers Overdo Critical devices like heaters that require electricity. Preppers that live in areas that get cold need to have a way to heat their houses that doesn’t use electricity. Additionally, they need to learn things like how to both shut off the water in their houses at the main valve and drain the system, in case of a long term outage in the winter (so pipes won’t burst). Trust nothing that requires power in an emergency.
SO… there are 8 items, there are many more we could have mentioned, so you can expect a follow up article in the future.
We don’t expect you to agree with all of them, our goal is to encourage you to think about it and debate whether we are right or are full of beans.
Like this post? Try 12 Prepper Lessons We Can Learn From Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Book “The Long Winter”!

Good list, Salty. I think you’ve pegged the biggies.
Seems like items 1, 2 and 3 all stem from a common misconception that SHTF will turn the world into Fallujah. So, they gear up like Marines. You’re right that shooting is fun and a worthwhile skill to acquire. Yet, it can be overdone. (Do people drive around with five spare tires…just in case?)
Guns, ammo, knives and tacticool seem to easily suffer the same fate as your #5, FreezeDried Foods. They become a sort of golden lifeboat in their minds: THE thing that will “save” them. Once some people have their golden lifeboat, they tend to stop prepping. They think they’ve got it all covered. (“16 MBRs and 10K rounds will save me…”)
The last part of your #5 hits an important point. Being able to grow your own food will be mission critical. The only reason everyone could keep fighting in Fallujah was because they had supply networks feeding them. Take away the daily rations and how long would they keep fighting? People scrounging to find food (or grow it) are too busy to attack en masse. Small skirmishes here and there? Probably. Full-on prolonged battles? Not likely.
Marketers know that farming isn’t sexy. Tacticool gear and black rifles stroke the ego much better than dirty hands and a shovel. Still, warriors got to eat too.
— Mic
I have to tell you that I agree with every item that you listed. The other thing that so many articles have listed has to do with a “Bug Out Bag”. Anyone who thinks they will be able to walk into the woods with what they have on their back is probably going to die within 6 weeks and probably less than that. I believe in having a survival bag in my cars especially during the winter due to weather problems that will hit when away from home. Worst I have seen has been an ice storm that I was not prepared for which happened about 25 years ago. Have enough in your vehicle for two days for two people. You have done a real service in bringing these points to light. Main item that I have determined necessary for a bug out location is POWER. This doesn’t need to be electrical necessary but if relying on wood then think about how much is needed to be cut and split for devices such as stoves and fireplaces as you stated. I do believe in the axiom that “2 is 1 and 1 is none” for critical items. Evaluate a bub out location thoroughly and determine what the single points of failure there are and work on providing redundancy.
Thank you. You have hit the nail on the head. It’s not about all of the cool stuff, it’s about having your bases covered and being able to care for those you love.
In a emergency if you have Tenna Mesh you turn your cell phone into a walk-in talkie. The single is boasted from other Mesh devices. All prepares should have these. I have no financial interest in this company. You should at least check it out.
Great list! So how about a list / article on 8 things we under-prep?
Well, we have this post with six.
Really well thought out list. The comment re: bug out bag is a good one. It costs a decent chunk of money to outfit a bag for each family member. Once assembled it sits, and sits, and sits …
We have get home bags instead. Once home we intend to stay at home unless under dire threat or poor health. We can pack our “bug out” bags while home and use the items that would go into it in our day to day lives.
Ref #5, raising your own food, if you don’t know how to store or preserve This food, it will likely spoil before you eat it. Learn about storing stuff like potatoes and squash in a cellar or in a pit. A lot of the food can be canned but you will need a supply of jars and lids. Jars can be cleaned and reused but the flats can’t. Get lots. They make good barter items. You will also need salt, both iodized and not. Sugar, vinegar etc.etc.
You need bugout bags for your vehicles. Everyone assumes they’ll be home when SHTF. You may be at work or out and about.
Agreed; a car bag by whatever name is important. It’s the percentage of time and attention to every minor detail of said bag, at the expense of other prepping, that Salty and I think is overdone.